The Courage of Bishop Michael Power: Crucial For Our Times

In 1842, when Father Michael Power, a Haligonian born of Irish parents, was consecrated as the first bishop of the newly formed Diocese of Toronto, he faced an enormous challenge. The Toronto Diocese, largely forgotten by Rome at that time, covered a vast area. Spanning the western area of Upper Canada, the diocese included Manitoulin Island to the north, London to the west, Niagara to the south and Toronto as the home base. He was the spiritual Father to fifty thousand Catholics with three thousand of them living in Toronto. The diocese was lacking in key areas. In a 1842 letter to Bishop Kinsella of Ireland, he wrote, “I have but twenty clergymen throughout the whole county…. I have neither colleges, nor schools, nor men.” One of his first actions was to gather the clergy at St. Paul’s Church in Toronto for a retreat and synod at which he issued strict rules for the conduct of his unruly priests and governance of the diocese. At this time, he consecrated  Toronto Diocese to the Sacred Heart of Jesus.

Bishop Power travelled extensively throughout the expansive region. Realizing the need for a nucleus – a central point – for the diocese, he set about the work of building a cathedral and bishop’s palace.  Construction of St. Michael’s Cathedral began in April, 1845.  He did not live to see its dedication on September 29, 1848.

In the 1840s the famine in Ireland caused mass immigration to Canada. Ninety thousand immigrants landed at Quebec City in 1847 and many of them continued the  journey to a new life in Toronto. Overcrowded and unsanitary condition on the ships as well as spoiled, inadequate food resulted in outbreaks of typhus en route to Canada.

Typhus raged in Toronto at this time, the large infected Irish population spreading the disease as they arrived in Hogtown. By 1847, eight hundred sixty-three people had died from the infection, their bodies buried in deep trenches near St. Paul’s Church.

Bishop Power led a courageous group of Catholic clergy and laymen, and assisted by Anglican Bishop J. Strachan, they went out to tend to the sick and the dying confined to fever sheds built along the wharves. Far from hiding behind locked church doors, they worked tirelessly on the forefront of the devastation.  Bishop Power contracted the disease and died on October 1, 1847. He was 42 years old.

The newspaper in his hometown of Halifax, The Cross, paid tribute to Bishop Power:

The loss to the Diocese of Toronto which Dr. Power distinguished by the value of his sacred offices, and the virtues of his life – is at this moment heavy and severe. It is said that neither night nor day witnessed his absence from depositaries of disease, until at length, kneeling over the bed of infection, and listening to the sorrows of some poor penitent, he inhaled the miasmata of death.”

In the one hundred seventy-eight years since the establishment of Toronto Diocese, much has changed.  Canada’s largest Archdiocese has a Catholic population of almost two million people served by two hundred twenty-six parishes within an area that is smaller than the original boundaries. One wonders what Bishop Power would say if he were to walk our streets today. One also wonders what he would say about the lockdowns that have been mandated during this time of covid infections.

On November 20, 2020, the Ontario Government, in an attempt to curb the increase in covid infections, misguidedly mandated that all places of worship must limit attendance to ten people. Note that the government did not demand the suspension of public worship. In response, the Archdiocese of Toronto decreed that as of November 23, 2020, all parishes in the city of Toronto and Peel region must stop all public Masses until further notice. No Holy Sacrifice of the Mass despite the fact that churches have been following strict sanitation, social distancing and masking guidelines and to date, have not been a source of outbreaks. The faithful have been encouraged to rely on livestreamed Masses, a poor and increasingly demoralizing substitute for being in the presence of the Lord in His Holy House.

In Toronto, Peel and everywhere that churches have prohibited public Mass, what would Bishop Power say? How would he lead during the current crisis? Would he pour himself out in leadership and service to an increasingly dispirited flock or would he surpass the ten-person government mandate and take away the public celebration of the Holy Sacrifice, removing public, in-person worship from Catholics badly in need of hope, badly in need of Christ?

We will never know his answer but we have the example of his life. In a time of fear and contagion, the good Bishop neither prohibited the celebration of Holy Mass nor hid from his people. In a Catholic Register staff editorial from June 8, 2017, Cardinal Thomas Collins lauded Bishop Power’s “sacrifice and service.” According to the editorial, Bishop Power assuaged the sick and dying with “the experience of Heaven to those who were suffering that hell.” In our present situation, we need the authority, sacrifice, service and courage of Bishop Michael Power.

Sacred Heart of Jesus, have mercy on us.


Michael Power: First Bishop of Toronto.

Wise, L. & Gould, A. Toronto Street Names: An Illustrated Guide To Their Origins. Richmond Hill: Firefly Books, 2011.