Catholic Insight
Catholic Insight  
Monday March 22, 2010

Home
Editorials
Features
Bioethics
Christian Jewish
Church
> Biographies
> Divorce
> Ecumenism
> Education
> Family
> Humanae
> Interreligious
> Liturgy
> Vatican
> World
> World
Controversy
Culture
 
Feminism
Political
> Abortion
> Euthanasia
> Homosexuality
> Israel
> Native
> Population
> Supreme Court
> U.N.
Saints
Social
Theology
Reviews - Books
Reviews - Films

RSS and Headlines

Feminism
Feminism

Excommunication for participation in "Ordination" of women reiterated
By Staff
Issue: July/August 2008

Email This Article  Printer Friendly Page  

Rome – On May 30, 2008 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith restated its earlier condemnation of women seeking ordination.  In the case of an attempted female ordination, both the candidate and the person performing the ceremony incur automatic excommunication (latae sententiae).  Neither the Holy See nor the local bishop needs to intervene: the excommunication is automatic.

Actually, the issue of women’s ordination died years ago.  Pope John Paul II in his 1994 apostolic letter “On the Priestly Ordination of Women,” made it clear that the Church had “no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women,” and that this was in fidelity to the will and example of Jesus.

However, in its charity for wayward people, the Vatican feels it necessary from time to time to remind the faithful of earlier conclusions and statements because some are hard of hearing. The issue, for example, continues to be discussed in some liberal Catholic publications.  Commonweal magazine, for example, published the article “Why not ordain women?” by Robert J. Egan, S.J. on April 11, 2008. 

On May 29, with a United Church as the venue, Victoria, BC was the scene of the “ordination” of Monica Kilburn Smith of Calgary who thereby promptly entered the ranks of the excommunicated “Womenpriests,” following in the footsteps of two other Canadian women who were “ordained” in 2002. Proponents of female priests argue that as in the case of ordaining married men, there is a need for women priests due to a worldwide shortage or priests.  Others, including some of Kilburn Smith’s supporters, claim that excluding women is tantamount to “gender apartheid” (Graeme Morton, Calgary Herald, May 4, 2008.)  Their understanding of the Catholic Church is sociological (a product of society), not theological (founded by Divine Revelation.)


© Copyright 1997-2006 Catholic Insight
    Updated: Aug 18th, 2008 - 13:05:53 

Top of Page





Latest: Feminism

 Excommunication for participation in "Ordination" of women reiterated
 The 'ordination' of 'womenpriests'
 Update: Women's ordination
 Joan Chittister disloyalty as obedience
 No diaconate courses for women